ActiveResidential · sale

189 S SAGE DR

Fish Lake, UT 84701

$450,000

  • 4 beds
  • 2 baths
  • 1,986 sq ft
  • 0.1 acres
  • Built 1950

Listed by Equity Real Estate (NRE) · MLS #2166379

Listing status & updates
MLS last changed
Not supplied by this listing source
Availability last checked
No per-listing check is recorded

Source changes and availability checks are different. A website import or photo check does not confirm that a property is still available. Confirm availability with the listing agent. Ask about the listing status

189 S SAGE DR, Fish Lake, UT 84701 — photo 1 View full photo
1 / 49

Interested in this property?

Team ERA is here to help. Tell us what you’re looking for, and we’ll connect you with a local ERA professional.

Schedule a showingAsk a question
Contact the property team

PROPERTY QUESTIONS & SHOWINGS

Ask about this property.

189 S SAGE DR, Fish Lake, UT 84701 · MLS #2166379

Your preferred tour

Times are local to the property. Your tour is not scheduled until an agent confirms.

Your purchase plans

Property inquiries go to help@erabrokers.com.

A FEW THINGS TO NOTICE

What stands out.

Living spaces

The main level features a spacious kitchen with pantry, updated propane range, cozy living room with fireplace, three bedrooms, and a full bathroom.

Year built

Built in 1950.

Garage parking

2 garage spaces listed.

Highlights from the listing description and property details. Confirm features with the listing agent.

THE PROPERTY

Get to know the property.

Escape to the mountains and enjoy one of Fish Lake's larger and more desirable cabins! Nestled among the aspens in the Aspen Heart Summer Homes area, this fully furnished 4-bedroom, 2-bath cabin offers 1,986 square feet of comfortable mountain living with breathtaking views, abundant parking, and a rare detached garage. The main level features a spacious kitchen with pantry, updated propane range, cozy living room with fireplace, three bedrooms, and a full bathroom. Downstairs you'll find a large family and gathering room with a second fireplace, additional sleeping space, a second bathroom, laundry room, and private exterior entrance-perfect for hosting family and friends after a day of fishing, boating, ATV riding, or exploring Fish Lake. Recent improvements include a new propane water heater, new propane range, updated luxury vinyl plank flooring in the kitchen, and a large propane tank installed in 2025. The detached garage includes workshop space plus room for a fishing boat and trailer, making it ideal for outdoor enthusiasts.One of the most unique features of this property is its size. Current Forest Service regulations limit new cabins in the Fish Lake Basin to 1,500 square feet, but this cabin is grandfathered at nearly 2,000 square feet, making it a rare opportunity to own one of the larger cabins in the area. Enjoy modern conveniences including internet service with Wi-Fi capability for streaming and improved cell service, while still experiencing the peace and beauty of mountain living. Whether you're looking for a family retreat, a seasonal getaway, or a place to create lasting memories, this Fish Lake cabin is ready to enjoy from day one. "Whether you're creating family traditions, escaping to the mountains, or investing in a rare Fish Lake retreat, this is a property you'll be proud to own. Come see it today and discover why opportunities like this don't stay available for long."
Explore the locationMore properties in Fish Lake

THE NEIGHBORHOOD

Explore the location.

189 S SAGE DR, Fish Lake, UT 84701

Loading property map…

Map position comes from the listing source. Open directions in Google Maps

LOCAL MARKET CONTEXT

Sevier County housing market

See the broader conditions surrounding this property through ERA Brokers Consolidated research.

12-month price trend$343,425Up 1.3% vs. the previous 12 months
Months of supply5.412-month average
Days on market7112-month weighted average

Latest available data: August 2026. Research by ERA Brokers Consolidated.

Explore the full market report

These figures describe the broader reporting area and do not determine this property’s value, condition, availability, or likely sale price.

THE DETAILS

The details, all in one place.

Property type
Residential
Category
Residential
Year built
1950
Garage spaces
2
Heating
Electric
Appliances
Gas Grill/BBQ,Refrigerator
Flooring
Carpet,Vinyl
Utilities
Natural Gas Connected,Sewer: Septic Tank,Water Connected
Pool
No
Spa
No
Subdivision
ALL OF LOT 69 ASPEN HEART SUMMER HOME SURVEY FISH
Zoning
Single-Family
Parcel
F-AH-SAGE DR 2
Elementary school
Ashman
Middle school
Red Hills
High school
Richfield
Annual property tax
$1,688.00

Features and school information are supplied by the listing source. Confirm measurements, school assignments, HOA terms and rental restrictions before making a decision.

Investor outlook Rental potential, ownership costs and property management

OWNERSHIP, WITH A PLAN

Investor outlook.

Explore this property’s rental potential with an all-cash purchase. Monthly rent starts at 5% of the purchase price per year, divided by 12. Adjust it and the other assumptions to explore your scenario.

These are planning assumptions, not a rental appraisal or a loan quote. The starting rent is a price-based estimate; a local leasing professional can help confirm market rent.

Investor outlook assumes an all-cash purchase. No mortgage payment is deducted.

Estimated monthly cash flow · cash purchase$1,206.42
Estimated monthly rent$1,875.00
Cap rate3.47%

Annual operating income: $15,602.00

HOA: No HOA cost is included because the listing source does not report one. Confirm whether HOA dues apply before relying on this estimate.

Have ERA review this rental estimate

Your property and current assumptions will be included for our team to review.

Adjust assumptions
Purchase price
Rental income & operating costs

Purchase price × 5% ÷ 12. Updates with purchase price until you enter a custom rent.

Annual insurance starts at purchase price × 0.25%, rounded to the nearest available amount. Updates with purchase price until you choose another amount.A planning estimate, not an insurance quote. Adjust it for your property and coverage.

Percentages are editable examples, not ERA fee quotes. Management is applied to rent after vacancy; maintenance and capital reserves use scheduled rent. Add owner-paid utilities, mortgage insurance and other recurring expenses under other costs.

How this scenario is calculated

Annual operating income is rent after vacancy, management, maintenance, taxes, insurance, HOA and other operating costs, before financing and capital reserves. Cap rate divides annual operating income by purchase price. Estimated monthly cash flow assumes an all-cash purchase: rent after vacancy, management, maintenance, taxes, insurance, HOA, other operating costs and capital reserves. No mortgage payment is deducted. The mortgage calculator is separate; loan payments would reduce cash flow for a financed purchase. One-time acquisition costs, renovations, income taxes, depreciation and appreciation are excluded.

Mortgage payment calculator

Explore financing separately. These loan settings do not change the all-cash investor outlook.

Mortgage assumptions

20% down and 7% interest are illustrative starting values.

Estimated monthly principal & interest—Loan payment only. Excludes property taxes, homeowners/flood insurance, mortgage insurance and HOA dues.

About this payment estimate

Based on a fixed-rate, fully amortizing loan with monthly payments and the price, down payment, interest rate and term you select. The interest rate is an example, not a current rate offer or APR; APR includes certain loan costs. This is an illustration, not a Loan Estimate, approval, offer of credit or commitment to lend.

Your actual payment, rate and eligibility depend on your lender, credit, loan program and property. Closing costs, points, prepaid expenses and lender fees are not included. Taxes and insurance may change, and mortgage insurance may be required, particularly with a down payment below 20%. Ask your lender for a Loan Estimate and a complete monthly payment including applicable taxes, insurance and fees.

Dollar results are rounded to the nearest cent; calculations retain precision until display. A cash purchase has no loan payment but still has ownership costs. Understand your total home payment (CFPB).

ERA PROPERTY MANAGEMENT

A team for what comes next.

Put your investment outlook into practice. Team ERA can help you confirm local rental potential and plan for the day-to-day of ownership.

  1. Understand the opportunity.

    Review rental pricing, property condition and your ownership goals with a local professional.

  2. Make a strong first impression.

    Bring together property preparation, professional marketing and applicant screening.

  3. Stay connected to your investment.

    Get support with rent collection, resident communication, maintenance coordination and owner reporting.

Get a local rental estimateTalk through your management needs
Stone-front home with a landscaped lawn and central entry
A more complete plan for your property

LOCAL PEOPLE. SHARED COMMITMENT.

A team behind your next step.

From your first question to the everyday work of ownership, a conversation with the right person makes a difference.

Meet ERA Property Management

Residential management in Utah, Nevada and Texas. Service availability and rental eligibility must be confirmed for each property. Commercial and association services are available through our management services page.

More in Fish Lake.

2033 W SLEEPY SAGE LN$949,0002033 W SLEEPY SAGE LNFish Lake, UT2031 S QUAKIE RD$1,999,0002031 S QUAKIE RDFish Lake, UT114 S JUNIPER DR$589,000114 S JUNIPER DRFish Lake, UT

Listing information

MLS #2166379 · Utah Real Estate MLS

Listing brokerage: Equity Real Estate (NRE)
Listing agent: Ryan Dastrup

Listing status: Active. MLS last changed: not supplied. Availability last checked: not recorded. Confirm current availability and price with the listing agent.

Based on information from the Wasatch Front Regional Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All data, including all measurements and calculations of area, is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be, verified by broker or the MLS. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.